A castle, a history, Echire

Critiques [Translate]

•  
• snunney (118519)
• [2012-09-13 3:39]

Hello Joël,
The information board in the foreground obviously depicts the castle in a former time in a more complete state. One wonders how long ago and how the dereliction occurred. A well framed composition with attractive natural colours and some interesting shadow play across the foreground. Fine technical quality.

•  
• pierrefonds (79441)
• [2012-09-13 4:42]

Bonjour Joël,

Les arbres cadrent bien les ruines du château. La prise d evue permet de voir les détails et les couleurs des ruines du château de Mursay. La bonne luminosité rehuasse les couleurs de l'image. Bonne journée.

Pierre

•  
• Sergiom (101792)
• [2012-09-13 5:02]

Bonjour Joel,

Cela prendrait vraiment quelqu'un très en moyens pour redonner vie à ce château. Mais comme vos riches ont décidé de quitter le pays et pour cause, laissez l'état s'en charger. En attendant, il va nous rester les belles photos prises.

Amicalement

Serge

•  
• sandpiper (6788)
• [2012-09-13 5:04]

Hi Joel

Another interesting note. I do enjoy reading your notes, so well researched, congratulations.
Great composition

Chris

•  
• Zucca (8)
• [2012-09-13 10:03]

Bonsoir Joël,

C'est une bonne idée d'avoir associé, sur la même photo, la carte postale ancienne et l'état actuel du château, dont les ruines font, hélas, peine à voir ! J'espère que l'association qui s'est créée lui redonnera son lustre passé, mais il y a du travail : plus de toit, des fenêtres bouchées aux moellons...

Bonne soirée,

Sylvain

•  
• Nicou (165906)
• [2012-09-13 10:13]

Hello Joël,

Fantastique cpatage ce château prsque en ruine avec la photo qui le montre en bon état, très bel ensemble bien vu nous nous montrer l'ensemble.

Bravo et amitié

Nicou

•  
• Fis2 (120713)
• [2012-09-13 12:46]

Witaj Joel!
Interesting ruins.
Curious photo.
I like colors and sharpness.
Good idea with an old picture.
Have a nice evening
Krzysztof

•  
• TopGeo (38216)
• [2012-09-13 13:04]

Hello Joel! Castle is really beautiful Aside from the beauty of this architecture, I especially like the POV you choose to present us this scene. The image has also fantastic clarity and depth and despite shadow weather very good lighting and well-saturated colors. Superb composition.
best regards
Georgios

•  
• carlo62 (65749)
• [2012-09-13 14:54]

Ciao Joel
hai fatto un ottimo lavoro, l'immagine così composta ha un senso, sarebbe stata meno interessante senza la cartolina in basso a destra.
Saluti
Carlo

•  
• Budapestman (82620)
• [2012-09-13 16:19]

Hi Joel,
a superb photo of this castle ruin with interesting note, the composition is very nice, great shot, Tfs! Have a nice week! Kellemes hetet kívánok!
György

•  
• Sonata11 (34009)
• [2012-09-13 19:50]

Hello Joel,
fantastic picture and great observation. I really like your executed photo. An amazing comparison with the documentary image. Very curious history of those ruin.
Beautiful composition lika always. I leki it very much. Thanks you.
All the best,
Barbara

•  
• jjcordier (79297)
• [2012-09-13 22:55]

Joël
Tu as réussi à agripper en même temps le château et sa représentation en images. Un souhait, maintenons le en l'état, si c'est encore possible! Heureusement il restera tes bonnes photos pour l'histoire.
Amicalement
JJ

•  
• kato (11630)
• [2012-09-13 23:14]

Hello Joel,

You're capturing well this medieval castle of the ruin by a good angle and excellent tone/clarity, so it's interesting and impressive to see old castle surrounded to green grass and trees. It looks like a stone-made strong fort. It's effective for the photograph of the castle in the lower right.
Have a nice day.

Kind regards,
mikio

•  
• mirosu (16313)
• [2012-09-14 12:28]

Bonsoir Joel,
A great use of light. The deep depth of field is perfect. A well presented crop allows eyes to remain fixed on the castle. This is a really excellent photo, and is a good example of architectural mode. The great light on the castle and the blue sky with white clousd also lends a lovely contrast to the scene. Well done.

•  
• marcan44 (6315)
• [2012-09-14 13:12]

Ciao Joel,
le rovine hanno sempre un fascino ed in questo caso trattandosi di un castello storico ancora maggiore.
Nel WS si può ammirare la location nel suo complesso.
Una immagine molto nitida con una resa di colori perfettamente naturale.
Complimenti, TFS !
Belle soirée
Amicalment
Mario

•  
• Silvio1953 (168539)
• [2012-09-15 3:33]

Ciao Joel, great view of fantastic castle, lovely composition with B&W photo in FG, excellent clarity, splendid light and colors, very well done, my friend, have a good week end, ciao Silvio

•  
• macjake (80625)
• [2012-09-16 23:10]

Hi Joel
this one is very interesting.
I like that we can see how the Castle looked in its hay day.
and even the windows are very recognizable.
its a shame it now looks the way that it does.
a fine idea with an effective result for the interested viewer.
cheers
craig